Got a new tenant for Condo #1

April 11th, 2007 by Kenric

My net tenant is moving in June 1st and my old tenant moves out May 31st.  This condo has been rented for every single day I’ve owned it.  I got this condo rented using my optimacondos.com website that I posted about earlier.  I really don’t understand why more people haven’t used my free site because it gets decent traffic and draws only a very targeted audience.  The only people coming to my site are people who want to rent an optima condo.

The rents for this condo has increased every year.  I first rented it out for $1225.  Last year, I thought I got a great deal when I was asking $1595 and got $1700.  This year I was able to get $1750 for it.  I’m glad that all the landlords in this building have realized that the new HOA rules and high taxes warrant huge rent increases.  A 2 bedroom unit used to rent for $1800 and now they are asking $2600.

I had to incur a few new costs this year.  First, the HOA passed a few new rules last year that I talked about in my post HOA trying to limit investors in my condo building.  The HOA is charging a $250 moving in fee for any new person moving in.  I’m eating this cost.  I’m not sure if the other investors are charging this to their new tenants or not.

My second cost is to pay a realtor for finding me this tenant.  Now about this, I was sort of torn between paying her and not paying her.  Here’s what happened. ”Mary” found my condo on my website two weeks ago and called me directly.  She saw the place and then I didn’t hear from her again.  Last week, I get a call from a realtor saying that her client really likes my place and asks if I work with realtors.  I ask what her fee is, she says it’s 1/2 month’s rent, which is $875.  I tell her that I will pay her $400 and she agrees.  Well, it turns out that her client is “Mary.” 

So the dilemma is, do I owe her $400?   I had already agreed to pay her, but it turns out that I’ve been in contact with her client prior.  I don’t think I’m obligated to pay her.  However, the question is, would Mary have called me to rent my place if this realtor didn’t call me?  She hadn’t contacted me back.  What do you all think? 

I’ve decided to pay her because:

  1. I told her I would
  2. I don’t know 100% if I would have gotten my tenant without her
  3. It’s only $400
  4. She did the background check and credit report already so I didn’t have to pay for that

I haven’t received so many calls from realtors on this condo and their first question is “Do you work with realtors?”  I’ll always said “yes” but I wonder how they’d react if I said “no.”  It’s a lesson learned though, in the future, I’m only going to pay $200 and stipulate that if they reveal a client that I’ve had prior contact with that I’m not paying anything.

I also just received a 2008 tax adjustment for this condo.  It’s going up.  I’m going to fight this one, because the value of the condo has gone down since 2006.  I think that $4500 for a $250k condo is just crazy.  Maybe I’ve been living in Arizona too long.



  1. 5 Comments to “Got a new tenant for Condo #1
  2. I’d pay her. It’s not much and creates some goodwill. But you might also let her know her client already contacted you directly, but you’re paying her anyway. Anyways, she did do some work in pulling the credit report and background check. I don’t know if future agents will go for the $200 fee. If they do background checks and credit reports, that’ll probably eat up 1/3 of that amount.

    By Shaun on Apr 11, 2007

  3. I agree with exacty what Shaun said. Plus you have to protect your business honor in the eyes of the agent.

    By Shawn on Apr 11, 2007

  4. The reason I’m hesitant to pay the fee is because I don’t feel that I need a realtor’s help to get this rented. The demand for this building is pretty high. However, you know what they say, “a bird in hand is better than two in the bush.” So I’ll take the first qualified person no matter what. I think that she was just happy that I was going to pay her anything. She seemed like a nice realtor that would have given me the info if I said no.

    By Kenric on Apr 11, 2007

  5. I’d pay her just to create a relationship…. if you are nice to her now she could probably think about you next time she has a renter… next time you talk to her mention your other properties so she checks with you for the next renters. In any case, congrats in renting the place this quickly without losing rents.

    By Andres on Apr 11, 2007

  6. I’d pay her for the reasons mentioned above. However, I would first explain your situation and say basically what you wrote here–that you thought you were already in contact with Mary, but that you would pay her because you are man of your word. That way the realtor KNOWS that you are paying her because you are keeping your word NOT because she deserves a finder’s fee.

    By Breadman on Apr 11, 2007

Post a Comment